The poverty wars and impossibly low poverty line of India

The poverty wars and impossibly low poverty line of India

By: V Raghunathan CEO, GMR Varalakshmi Foundation

Swaminathan Anklesaria Aiyar (TOI March 25 and ET March 28) has strongly defended the Planning Commission's stance that there is nothing amiss with the poverty line drawn at Rs 22.40 in rural areas and Rs 28.65 in urban areas (down from initial estimates of Rs ...32 and Rs 26, respectively).

Let us discount the copious tears being shed by various politicians and their parties on this new line of poverty as crocodilian, because after all, it is this class that is largely responsible for some 300 million Indians earning below this pathetic line six decades after Independence.

Let us also discount the parallel drawn between the Planning Commission's poverty line and that of the World Bank, which may be in the same street at $1.25 or Rs 23.75 per day based on the PPP dollar (where Rs 19 equals $1).

This figure may be representative of poverty in sub-Saharan Africa, but is hardly becoming of an ambitious, welfare-minded emerging nation, aspiring to a permanent seat in the United Nations Security Council.

So let us apply some common sense to the problem. The poverty line cannot be dissociated from a poor man's daily needs for subsistence. Swaminomics defines key ingredients of subsistence for the poor at 400 gm (or 8 @ 20 per kg) of wheat and 100 gm of chana dal (or Rs 4.50 @ Rs 45 per kg) to ensure a daily intake of 2,000 calories and little besides. That accounts for Rs 12.50 for basic food.

If accepted, this leaves about Rs 10 or Rs 14, for the rural or urban poor, per day for a most basic roof over his or her head; such expenses as cooking fuel; cooking oil; salt and chilly; other basic spices like turmeric, garlic, an odd onion (or is it a luxury now?); may be a cup, if not two, of tea every day; a whiff of spinach or cabbage occasionally; not to speak of two bed clothes - a sheet on the top and a coarse throw on the floor.

We agree that a poor man deserves no pillow. Maybe, two dhotis or pyjamas or saris with two blouses or shirts each. We should remember at least one set of warm clothes for winters and utensils like a metal pot, pan and serving spoon, an occasional earthen or plastic pot to fetch and store water, a bucket, chakla, belan, tava and a pan for the dough to make chapatis.

The poor will still need a bar of soap, a kerosene stove in places where firewood or coal is hard to come by and is certainly not free. She will also need a pair of plastic slippers, a blue tarpaulin and some nylon rope to reinforce the roof every other year and occasional access to local transportation.

What could be the cost of a very basic roof over a poor man's head? Is a 10x10 square foot abode for a family of four acceptable? If so, at a monthly rental of 5 to 6 per sqft (depending on rural or urban areas), such a dwelling for four must cost about or Rs 500 to Rs 600 per month or Rs 4 to Rs 5 per day per person.

And if you assume that even the most wretched deserve the dignity of a latrine, unless it is a national policy that the poor must forever defecate on streets or fields, even the cheapest public lavatory costs Rs 1 per visit per person per day in rural and Rs 2 in urban areas. At two visits a day, that is another 2 or 4 per person per day. So that's Rs 6 or Rs 8 just for shelter, leaving between Rs 4 and Rs 5 to the rural or urban poor for other day-to-day requirements.

Surely neither Montek Ahluwalia nor Swaminathan Aiyar considers any of the above as luxuries?